Tories spend staggering £100million trying to stop disabled getting help they’re entitled to
The Tories have been spending a fortune every year on attempts to stop sick and disabled people receiving state benefits – not because the claimants don’t deserve it, but because they like hurting the vulnerable.
The figures don’t exactly tie together – because government figures never do; they aren’t meant to – but they are still a damning indictment of the Conservative government.
The figures show that the Tories have thrown away more than £100 million a year on legal battles against people who are physically and mentally unfit to go to court – and have lost two-thirds of them.
Those figures indicate serious abuse of the system by those who are supposed to be its stewards.
But it’s all right – they’ve got a rigged “satisfaction” survey that says most people are happy with the treatment they receive.
It seems to be time for more legal action.
Freedom of Information requests exposed how taxpayers’ cash has been spent on futile legal battles to prevent vulnerable people receiving help.
The Department for Work and Pensions spent £108.1million on appeals against disability benefits in just two years, new figures reveal.
Neil Heslop, chief executive of disability charity Leonard Cheshire, said: “To spend this amount on admin fighting to uphold flawed decisions that shouldn’t have been made in the first place is staggering.
“Thousands of disabled individuals have had to fight to receive support to which they are legally entitled.”
The huge sum is in addition to the tens of millions of pounds spent every year by the Ministry of Justice on the appeals, around two-thirds of which have been won by claimants in the past year.
The bill prompted a Tory former minister to claim “something is seriously wrong with the system”.
The DWP said a small proportion of decisions were overturned and most Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) and Personal Independence Payment (PIP) claimants were happy with their assessments.
But the department is also facing questions from the Work and Pensions select committee over the figures, amid claims it was not given similar information for its own inquiry into PIP and ESA.
Figures obtained through a Freedom of Information request show the DWP has spent £108.1million on direct staffing costs for ESA and PIP appeals since October 2015.
The figure covers mandatory reconsiderations, an internal DWP review, and appeals to tribunals run by HM Courts and Tribunals Service.
The monthly cost has been steadily rising and in December the DWP spent £5.3million on mandatory reconsiderations and appeals for PIP and ESA.
The equivalent figure for October 2015 was £2million.
Since October 2015, 87,500 PIP claimants had their decision changed at mandatory reconsideration, while 91,587 claimants won their appeals at tribunal.
In the first six months of 2017/18 some 66% of 42,741 PIP appeals went in the claimant’s favour.
The figures for ESA since October 2015 show 47,000 people had decisions revised at mandatory reconsideration and 82,219 appeals went in the claimant’s favour.
So far in 2017/18, 68% of 35,452 ESA appeals have gone in favour of the claimant.
Tory peer Baroness Altmann, a former DWP minister, said the money could be spent on benefits for those who need them, rather than on the costs of fighting claims.
She said: “Disability benefits need an overhaul and, of course, we must not let people make bogus claims, but the extent of the appeals we are seeing clearly indicates that something is seriously wrong with the system.”
Figures released to the select committee’s inquiry show further costs to taxpayers.
The Ministry of Justice says it spent £103.1million on social security and child support tribunals in 2016/17, up from £92.6million the year before and £87.4million in 2014/15.
Around 190,000 cases were cleared with or without a hearing in 2016/17, it told the committee.
Disability benefits make up the bulk of these tribunals, with 136,052 hearings held for either PIP or ESA claims in the same year, according to MoJ figures.
In a letter to the select committee, then justice minister Dominic Raab said the average cost of an appeal had more than doubled to £579 in 2014/15 because PIP cases “now comprise a much larger proportion of the caseload”.
PIP cases require more members on the tribunal panel which increases the average cost, he said.
The select committee is due to publish the results of its inquiry into PIP and ESA on Wednesday.
Chairman Frank Field has written to Esther McVey, the Work and Pensions Secretary, in the wake of the costs figures to question why MPs were not given such information.
The DWP gave the committee the average costs of a mandatory reconsideration and appeal for PIP and ESA.
But Labour MP Mr Field said the committee was unable to work out the full cost of the appeals process.
A DWP spokeswoman said it was working to improve the process, including recruiting around 190 officers who will attend PIP and ESA appeals to provide feedback on decisions.
“Assessments are a necessary part of the benefits system, and everyone has the right to appeal a decision if they’re unhappy,” she said.
“A vast majority of people are happy with their assessments, and only a very small proportion of all ESA and PIP decisions are overturned at appeal – just 4% for PIP and 5% for ESA.
So what do you think?
Tell us in the comments.
Source : https://voxpoliticalonline.com/2018/02/12/tories-wasted-more-than-100-million-in-two-years-on-persecuting-the-sick-and-disabled/
Source : https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/tories-spend-staggering-100million-trying-12010608
Who will hold the powerful to account?
Real, independent, investigative journalism is in alarming decline. It costs a lot to produce.
Many publications facing an uncertain future can no longer afford to fund it, meaning journalists are losing the ability to hold the rich and powerful to account.
Pledge as little as £1.00 to help us support independent investigative journalism